OverRated: The Week in College Football Polls Ugly Trophy Edition

Ugly Trophy Edition:  It turns out there are teams out there worse than MICHIGAN

This past week we learned that there is a college in Ypsilanti, so don’t go using that sweet town’s name in vain just because you want to make fun of Jim Harbaugh (personal motto:  I was born in Toledo!).  We also learned that GM’s Willow Run plant closed in 2010 (thanks, Obama), so we’ll need to pick on some other township the next time we want to make tranny jokes.

Out on the grid-iron, we book only two toldjasos™, but one comes at the high cost of conceding a mistake.  The week that was:

 

Week Six Most OverRated Football Program Results

1          Boise State unremarkably trounced entertainment engineering powerhouse UNLV

2          Wake Forest doesn’t play Unitas-less Louisville until next weekend (I misread their calendar)

3          Georgia finally took the all-time series lead over hapless Tennessee

4          Florida handled Auburn and child quarterback Nix

4          Iowa was corn-holed by the near-nobodies at Ann Arbor

6          Texas recovered from an early scare to survive at West Virginia

7          Auburn has a solid defense, but so does Florida, so they fell five places

7          Oregon quietly managed Cal

9          Oklahoma beat KU by only 25

 

Iowa’s not much to brag on, but some trophies are just uglier than others.  Ranked 14th, they gave up eight sacks to 19th ranked Michigan and fell, appropriately, four spots.

Auburn’s loss to Florida was a very even match, but in the polls your punishment is always all out of proportion to what happened at the game.  So Auburn falls five places, and they are now proven to have been at least a bit over-rated.  I can’t put it more succinctly than MSN:

. . . a game that was tense, sloppy, mistake-filled, oddly coached and generally impossible to figure out from possession to possession.  After four turnovers apiece and a whole bunch of other weirdness, it was No. 8 Florida blowing the game open on Lamical Perine’s 88-yard touchdown run with 9:04 remaining, giving the Gators a terrific win and a 6-0 record despite some very clear flaws. And for No. 7 Auburn, it was a reality check about life with a true freshman quarterback in Bo Nix, who seemed rather overwhelmed with the whole thing and made some truly terrible decisions . . .

 

This correspondent has trifled with Florida and had bagged them already earlier in the season when AP voters had lost their collective nerve over the Gators.  But now we must concede that any earlier call on UF was bull feathers and book them as a clear miss.  They feature a second-string quarterback, but, as usual, their defensive secondary is fearless and fast.  They’re still over-rated a place or two, but that’s still too close, so let’s just agree I was wrong on this one.

So snarking about the rankings is nearly dead for the year; there’s just not much new left to yell about from the peanut gallery.  Indeed, in my admittedly very slow news, I found that if you duckduckgo for “heckler” you get endless pictures of cool pistols; that’s all I learned this week.  Now . . . onto your season’s-under-way and Iowa-free rankings:

 

Newest Week N + 1 Post-Iowa Most OverRated Football Programs

1      Wake Forest will host Unitas-less Louisville as my All-Time Most OverRated Team of All-Time!!11!!

2      Minnesoda almost ties the Wake record with their ridiculous debut but should edge Nebraska by four

3       Memphis jumps onto our board; Temple won’t have a prayer against the Tiger Hype

4       Boise State hosts Hawaii

5       Georgia should roll over The Other USC

6       Texas meets worthy Oklahoma in the Red River Classic

7       Oregon should bulldoze Colorado

     Oklahoma meets worthy Texas in the Red River Classic

Honorable mentions – Utah is still over-ranked, but I’ve made enough fun of them already this year.  SMU should damp to their mean soon.  So how has our year gone so far?

 

Year to Date Hides on the Wall Rated

1          Utah lost to an unrated USC

2          Stanford was revealed by USC

2          Syracuse was unranked after Maryland

2          UCF was edged by an unranked Pitt

2          Iowa was no number 15 as Michigan proved

6          Cal was dumped from the AP after losing to Arizona State

6          Iowa State was dethroned before their decent showing against Iowa

6          Michigan State fell out of the ratings, so I was right after all

9          Clemson was dethroned by Mack Brown retirement project UNC

9          Texas probably over-paid for losing to titan LSU

9          Auburn probably over-paid for losing to Auburn

9          Texas A&M probably over-paid for quality losses against Clemson and Auburn

13        Washington State was unranked after becoming lowly UCLA’s first win

14        Michigan was blown out by Wisconsin

15        Virginia probably over-paid for losing to can-play-with-UGA Notre Dame

 

Year to Date It-Would-Seem Blown Calls Because They’re Doing Okay Really Well

1          LSU

2          Florida seems to have earned their status by defeating top-ten Auburn

3          UCF is now a skin on the wall after Pitt

4          Michigan no longer a blown call because Wisconsin

5          Washington State no longer a blown call because UCLA

Let’s score this year 152-3 so far, nothing to be ashamed of.  So closes another week!

 

 

links to older opinions:                  2019-10-03                  2019-09-26                  2019-09-19                  2019-09-13                  2019-09-06
Disclosure of sources of bias:  your writer has attended the University of Tennessee, Memphis State and the University of Memphis, Christian Brothers College . . . and he sleeps with an alumna of Georgia whose parents met at Washington State . . . and his son went to Houston . . . and he never met anyone from TCU he didn’t like . . . and he irrationally hates Notre Dame, UCF, Clemson, and Notre Dame.

Comments

181 responses to “OverRated: The Week in College Football Polls Ugly Trophy Edition”

  1. CPRM

    UNLV isn’t over-rated. Knew it.

    1. Don Escaped Texas

      I just wanted to show I’m paying attention.

      FWIW: UNLV is probably not a top 100 team.

      1. CPRM

        entertainment engineering powerhouse

        EXCUSE ME! #1 Hospitality program in THE WORLD!

        1. Don Escaped Texas

          I just found that to be a weird discipline.

          1. CPRM

            All them casino hotels need someone to run em.

          2. CPRM

            One of the guys I knew was a hospitality major, with an emphasis on running golf tournaments. He wanted to work the PGA, and that was real shit he was taking classes for.

          3. Teaching the world’s oldest profession.

        2. Hey hey hey! Cornell?!

          1. Rhywun

            That was my first thought too. Upstate NY FTW! ✊?

          2. *high five*

      2. CPRM

        I don’t pay attention to college football anyway. Too sloppy even at the top tier.

  2. Gender Traitor

    I had somewhat divided loyalties with one game last week. On the one hand, I was immersed in statewide peer pressure to wallow in Buckeyemania. On the other hand, my family shelled out a shit ton of out-of-state tuition for my oldest sister to go to Michigan State.

    Sorry, sis.

    1. Don Escaped Texas

      packaging engineers from MSU are solid; I probably prefer the cow colleges so far as publicly funded institutions go

      1. Gender Traitor

        Go Moo U!

  3. dbleagle

    I prefer to watch the Division 2 schools. When I taught at Montana State the games were university and community events. If I want to watch professional football I’ll watch the NFL and not the SEC, PAC-12, etc.

    But it is interesting to watch you take down the imposters.

    1. Don Escaped Texas

      overreaction seems to be the most constant dynamic in human events, all disciplines and endeavors considered

    2. Hey. We lived in Butte! Not Bozeman, loser.

    3. invisible finger

      College football is a tool of the state.

  4. dbleagle

    I give college ball shit but I love the game of football. I played organized tackle football for 10 years, and flag from then until I got brittle with age.

    If you ever played or had somebody you cared for that played football this song can make the room dusty.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GEc1m-r_0gM

  5. Sir Digby

    a game that was tense, sloppy, mistake-filled, oddly coached and generally impossible to figure out from possession to possession

    Sounds like a lot of dates I’ve been on.

    1. dbleagle

      I was called repeatedly on dates for “illegal use of hands” until one night, mirabile dictu, that I wasn’t.

      https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7c0__RenjD0

      1. Sir Digby

        More good music!

        1. CPRM

          Indeed, this song had a local resurgence around here when I was teen in the late 90s along with DADADA where at one point they were both featured on a local stations 9 at 9.

          1. Sir Digby

            It’s on quite a bit on the XM stations I listen to.

            OK–one of them. But, it’s never far away.

          2. Gustave Lytton

            Love that Casio VL1

  6. Sir Digby

    Half-relevant to this discussion: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aoWsPRzzia8

    Appropriate response: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UTNi48f567E

    1. dbleagle

      Since George brought up full contact chess.

      Can you guess?

      https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mnqj31VPNoE

      When Carlin was on he was on. Pure genius.

      1. Sir Digby

        I’m just glad this didn’t have anything to do with the Australian Dick Wrestling…

        Thank you for that small mercy.

      2. CPRM

        I was thinking more Sliders.

  7. dbleagle

    Trying to get to Tucson in time for classes after a climb went long. We were feeling great because we completed a first ascent. On a deserted I-8 heading east from Gila Bend late at night with a fat moon over the desert.

    This came on the radio and we were off to the races.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zf53Pg2AkdY

    1. Sir Digby

      At least it wasn’t this little ear-worm.

      1. Hey, did you get my email?

        1. Sir Digby

          Yes, I did! Thank you for the info and advice.

        2. Sir Digby

          BTW, do I need to do anything/take any actions re: my post?

          1. Sir Digby

            OK–just making sure.

          2. But I’m drinking because my life, so..,

          3. Sir Digby

            So….Cheers, then!

      2. CPRM

        Did I tell about the time I played a sesame street record backwards and it clearly said, “Meet Colonel Mustard at the bus stop.” I tried playing the White Album backwards and nothing; Ozzie, nothing; but those damn Sesame Street records had legit backwards masking.

        1. Sir Digby

          I admit to having owned Sesame Street Fever when I was a wee tyke.

          I may just be appropriating that idea, but I think I tried that once or twice….no idea what the outcome was. I guess I can just make something up…

          1. CPRM

            I don’t know which album it was. But, this is very true.

      3. dbleagle

        Damn. You are punishing me for “I’ve Never Been to Me”

        Here is a peace offering.

        https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7wRHBLwpASw&list=RDCLAK5uy_klY80tDUG8t6V0eXb5ttfGqRZZb8c5JZg&index=21

        1. Sir Digby

          That was a fine offering!

          However, I had/have no ill feelings over your choice from last night, as I listed to whatever mom listened to during that time, and I’m pretty sure it was in rotation on her channel of choice.

        2. Gustave Lytton
          1. Gustave Lytton

            And we’re to Sunglasses at Night. How fitting. Well played good Sir!

          2. Sir Digby

            Sunglasses at Night

            ? ?

  8. CPRM

    [oldest cohort] Millennial. LISTEN TO MY MUSIC, YOUR OLD PERSON MUSIC SUCKS! [entitlement end]

    1. Sir Digby

      Just yo wait for the inevitable 90’s nostalgia wave that will probably hit sometime in the next 3-5 years.

      1. CPRM

        That’s what I’ve been trying to say at the day job for the last 3 years…

        1. dbleagle

          Not bad.

          There was a great song which I spacing on from 2016. It had them singing in a prison on talking about getting the DT shakes. I always thought it was the perfect song for the election.

      2. Rhywun

        The recent Friends-mania says we’re already there.

        1. Gustave Lytton

          Look at Stranger Things, I think it’s hovering between decades.

          1. Sir Digby

            I think it’s pretty firmly planted in mid-80s. Back the the Future was somewhat prominent in this last season.

          2. Rhywun

            I don’t do Netflix so I can’t look at that.

        2. Sir Digby

          I definitely should have qualified it with “90’s music”.

          Wait….there’s been a Friends-mania recently?

          1. Rhywun

            25th anniversary celebration on the corner where the exterior shot of their apartment building was taken. There was some brou-ha-ha over it. Too local, for sure.

  9. CPRM

    Alt-right Sir Digby. This decayed form is weak and requires that stupid thing called sleep.

    1. Sir Digby

      Well, get unwrapped, and get some rest.

  10. Well, later boomers are the original punk rockers, so…,

    1. / OMWC doesn’t get it

  11. hayeksplosives

    Hi, gang!

    Sleep wants to take me away but I had to read this piece and join in for a while

    1. Sir Digby

      Howdy!

    2. Hey, Chica.

      I am drinking and canning. How are you feeling?

      1. dbleagle

        Howdy Hayek!

        Just the night crew here endangering our Family Friendly rating.

        1. Sir Digby

          Not based off of my music selections….

          ?

          1. dbleagle

            Is that a challenge?

          2. Sir Digby

            No, Sir! Just…making observations, as it were.

          3. Sir Digby

            Tonight!! I meant “tonight”!

    1. dbleagle

      Good find.

      1. Gonna be home anytime soon?

        1. dbleagle

          I might get out there around the turn of the year. I need to burn up some vacation and I miss the desert.

          1. We’d love to meet you. Long overdue!

          2. dbleagle

            Meeting your posse is at the top of my to do list.

            I’ll even bring a slice of pizza for the wunderhund.

          3. Woohoo! You may advance.

      2. straffinrun

        The beginning isn’t bad, but it gets hilarious here.

        https://youtu.be/uo8qXxnFuRQ?t=1101

        1. Sir Digby

          Oh, straff–that’s not gonna play well in certain households…..

          1. straffinrun

            Wherever the joke goes. I don’t control the comedy gods.

        2. dbleagle

          “Sweden is Mecca.” He nails it.

  12. Oh, and on topic….college what? Seriously, grown people care?

    1. dbleagle

      When I was in college the only thing I cared about the Uni team was that they closed off access to our dorm during the game. It was damn inconvenient if I was around.

      1. Sir Digby

        What a crock! Were you just supposed to stay put during the game, or, make arrangements somewhere else??

        “Can’t let ya in–Game.”

        “But, I live here!”

        “Can’t let ya in…”

  13. Nobody wants to challenge my punk cred?

    1. Sir Digby

      Challenge SP?

      Ohh…not pulling at that string!

      1. dbleagle

        Nope. I know only a few punk songs.

      2. Well, I was dialed in,….

        1. Sir Digby

          If I ever got my pretty libertarian friend involved here, he would most likely take you up on that challenge.

          Like, dbl, I only know a few as well.

          1. I was completely in that world, Bet we know the same small world. (But not Rhywun. He was too far east.)

  14. dbleagle

    This is a great way to watch some bands covering some older pieces. It gives you an idea of the complexity of the music. A small sample of the channel.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ljGMhDSSGFU

    1. Sir Digby

      That is quite interesting. Oddly, it scratches the Close Encounters itch at the same time (sorta). I like!

      1. dbleagle

        I have a buddy who was a percussionist. He hated it when I called his symphony a “cover band” or a “tribute band”.

        1. Sir Digby

          Heh!

  15. dbleagle

    Hayek, I received a 1972 Eisenhower Dollar in my change today. I think the last time that happened was in 1989 when I lived in Germany.

    1. dbleagle

      Well of to bed to read until I nod off.

      1. Sir Digby

        ‘Night!

    2. Whoa, cool.

      1. Sir Digby

        The simple, yet, rare pleasures in life are often the best.

    3. hayeksplosives

      Sweet! Yes, considering inflation, seems like it would make sense to have more in circulation

  16. OK, well, stupid stuff taking FOREVER to come up to temp.

    1. Sir Digby

      ::looks around::

      I guess I could more effort into it…

      What is it that isn’t the proper temp?

      1. NM green chile 200F.

        1. Sir Digby

          200 doesn’t seem all that high…is it particularly cold?

          1. No, just pressure canning.

          2. TARDIS

            I’m lonely. Someone sing me a song.

          3. TARDIS

            Nevermind. I thought I refreshed, but no. Stupid phone.

          4. Gender Traitor

            First one that came to mind. My personal audio antidepressant. I believe it may be physically impossible to feel down after hearing this.

          5. Gender Traitor

            (Hope I wasn’t too late!)

          6. TARDIS

            I’m here. No morning meetings for me. (Boss called in drunk) J/K

            I was listening to some of her other tunes. They’re nice and upbeat. The language is a good one for singing songs too;pretty even.

            I was looking for lyric translations also. I didn’t find a complete one for the tune you linked.

        2. Tejicano

          Maybe you have to rub them together faster?

          1. Um…. well….

          2. Sir Digby

            ::eyes water::

          3. Well….wanna hear “war stories?”

          4. Tejicano

            ‘s-up?

          5. Nah. Gruesome tales of EMS/Fire. Not everyone’s cuppa.

          6. Although Spud gets it…..

          7. Tejicano

            Seen a bit of that in the Marines. Fire is bad. Acid is worse by a bit.

            I was at the fire at Camp Fuji – 40 years ago next week. Not good.

          8. Sir Digby

            I’m good–seen/heard/read enough to last.

            Of course, I would still read if you ever wanted to do a gi-normous post or anthology…

            /just putting that out there

          9. Sir Digby

            I was at the fire at Camp Fuji

            Damn! Much respect.

          10. Tejicano

            No respect deserved. I just happened to be there. I knew a number of people burned and more who were able to escape basically unscathed.

            I am going to the memorial next week.

  17. Tejicano

    OK, my boy finished his homework. Back to waiting for the spousal unit to get home from work, Just checked my watch – looks like beer-thirty.

  18. Sir Digby

    Is it wrong to find this series quite enjoyable?

    Time doesn’t necessarily heal all wounds, but, it can make many things quite humorous.

    1. Tejicano

      Not sure. I kinda remember how my parents dressed like that – in photos. Social norms were much stricter in that time.

      1. Sir Digby

        Other than to a small extent in magazines (I’m looking at you, Teen Vogue), is this even a thing, any more?

        1. hayeksplosives

          I don’t think so, although I went to an optional “formal etiquette” all day course at my previous job in which we learned—and practiced at lunch—proper dinner etiquette. (who knew there was a correct direction to enter and exit the chai from?)

          We also learned rules for proper introductions, which side the name badge should be pinned to, etc.

          It was very gender specific and seemed so old fashioned as to be quaint.

          Weird.

          1. hayeksplosives

            (Chair, not chai for Pete’s sake)

          2. Sir Digby

            That is….I dunno–interesting, funny, weird, and, somewhat refreshing all in one.

          3. hayeksplosives

            The strict gender rules made me feel Ike the women there should all have been dressed like June Cleaver

          4. Sir Digby

            Ah! In all B&W…gotcha.

            /ducks, runs

            //not intending the “strict gender rules” to be refreshing…

          5. Gender Traitor

            ‘Mornin’, Diggy!

          6. Gender Traitor

            Chai is nice! I prefer mine in a latte. But coffee will have to do for now. ::takes her first sip:: ‘Mornin’, folks! How are you?

          7. hayeksplosives

            Good morning, GT!

            Barely hanging on here, and will definitely be getting more sleep before my early day gets going

          8. Gender Traitor

            Sleeping ever more comfortably, I hope?

          9. hayeksplosives

            Yeah, thanks.

            Only about 1 more month until my back is expected to be normal again.

          10. Gender Traitor

            Yay! We shall have to observe a Frabjous Day when it’s declared all better!

          11. Gender Traitor

            re: the etiquette training – did that org have very “old school” and/or international clients? All that stuff might still be de rigueur in some cultures/social contexts.

          12. hayeksplosives

            Not that I’m aware of. It was a local Minneapolis lady who did this for a living.

            Probably diplomats still use it. Maybe she does have international clients.

            Whatever the case, it felt like time travel.

          13. Gender Traitor

            Paging TARDIS, spotted somewhere upthread w/in last 10 min or so.

          14. Remember – rules of etiquette with absurd detail like that were invented by rich snobs for the sole purpose of separating them (the people with the time to waste on such things) from the hoi polloi, who did useful stuff.

  19. Tejicano

    Stepping out for dinner with the family. Catch ya later.

  20. Good morning. Yesterday I got the cross OS communication issue solved in concept, and the network flows that were causing serious production problems were finally sorted. I should feel less stressed today… but for whatever reason I’m not.

    1. Gender Traitor

      Hmmmm…. on days like that I rely on the SiriusXM “Spa” channel to keep me from killing co-workers. Any favored music of a soothing style?

      1. When I’m stressed or agitated, music exacerbates the problem. I’ll end up hitting skip every two seconds or so just to not hear songs I would otherwise listen to. I need to withdraw into someplace quiet, which I won’t get at work. (Very loud office neighbors) I just want to down some antacid and go back to sleep. Instead I’m at the office.

        1. Gender Traitor

          Well, crap. Is Friday a light at the end of the tunnel, i.e. you have the weekend off? (And maybe a 3-day, ‘cuz o’ Columbus Day?)

          1. If nothing breaks I should have three days off.

            But there’s firewall work scheduled for monday, so they might end up calling me in to test because that happens often enough. I plan to make pierogis and bring them to my mother’s place. I may need more cheese, since I used most of what was in the house already.

          2. Gender Traitor

            More cheese is always a good idea…as long as you’re getting enough fiber. (Cheese: “Milk’s leap to immortality” – The Joy of Cooking)

          3. Well, this cheese is going to get mixed with whatever fish they use to make imitation lobster and made into pierogi filling.

    2. Sean

      Good mornin.

      1. One can hope. How are things in your neck of the woods?

        1. Sean

          Optomistic.

          If I get through today, then I get a three day weekend and a getaway to the Poconos.

          1. Gender Traitor

            Noice! Hope local weather conditions have been conducive to some lovely autumnal foliage!

          2. Sean

            I’ll probably post some pics.

      2. Gender Traitor

        G’mornin’!

    3. I should feel less stressed today… but for whatever reason I’m not.

      I’ve been dealing with the same issue for the past few weeks. Late September and October suck in my department, but I pretty much hit my goals a week early. My jaw can unknot any time now…

  21. Sean

    https://hdontap.com/index.php/video/stream/pa-game-commission-elk-cam

    The elk are out.

    Yeah, I posted this a couple times, but it’s only on for a limited time. Plus, I find it very cool.

    1. Gender Traitor

      …in the misty morning fog…

      1. Well, you could have icy morning fog.

      2. TARDIS

        Sha la la la la la la la la la la te da

        1. Your avatar appears to have caught fire.

          1. TARDIS

            Mood swing.

          2. Gender Traitor

            Tenth Doctor regenerating, I believe, but I don’t remember if he was coming or going.

          3. Leaving, based upon the attire.

          4. Plus, when Nine left, he didn’t go scorched tardis on everything.

          5. Gender Traitor

            He didn’t want to go. : (

        2. Gender Traitor

          ^This guy gets it! Hi, TARDY! Did you see the song I “sang” you upthread?

          1. TARDIS

            Don’t make me come over there and scroll up for you!

          2. Gender Traitor

            Here ya go, Though I don’t suppose you’re lonely any more. Hope you enjoy anyway.

    1. Gender Traitor

      Hava tequila, baby!

  22. To carry ahead the conversation from last thread, I believe Monocle is set to refresh the thread every 45 seconds, not 3 minutes. The only exception is on mobile where the process may be hibernated when you shut the screen off.

    1. TARDIS

      You can also right it off, right m

      1. TARDIS

        Turn it off? Dammit, autocorrect!

  23. Gender Traitor

    Later, fellas!

      1. MikeS

        *polite applause*

    1. TARDIS

      C ya!